My extra creamy mashed potatoes are silky and rich, yet still light and simply seasoned to highlight the natural taste of potatoes. I use Yukon gold potatoes mashed with butter, heavy whipping cream, and crème fraiche, my little secret to a super creamy texture. The whole recipe takes about 40 minutes.
Take the dairy (heavy whipping cream, butter, and creme fraiche) out of the refrigerator, measure, and let it sit while cooking the potatoes so it warms up to room temperature.
Peel, rinse, and pat the potatoes dry. Chop them in half or fours depending on how big or small they are. Try to make sure the chunks are close to equal sizes so they cook at the same time.
Add potatoes into a pot that's big enough to fit them comfortably. Fill the pot with cold water, enough to cover the potatoes with about an inch of water over the top.
Place the pot on the stove and turn the heat on to high. Add in the 2 tsp of salt, 2 garlic cloves and 1 tsp of black pepper. (Don't worry, this will help flavor the potatoes as they cook but most of it will drain off with the water.)
Bring the potatoes to boil and lower the heat to medium. Let the potatoes cook, stirring them from time to time, until completely cooked through. To check, you can stick a fork into it to make sure it goes in and out easily. It will take 15-25 minutes, depending on the size of the potato pieces.
Cover the pot with a lid and strain off all the water. (Leave the garlic in.)
Place the pot back into the stove, take the lid off, and let the potatoes sit over medium heat for 1-2 minutes. This will cook off extra liquid on the bottom.
Take the pot off the heat and add the butter pieces. Let the butter melt for a few minutes.
Heat up the heavy whipping cream in the microwave for just about 10 seconds to get it warm. Add in creme fraiche and heavy whipping cream to the potatoes and use the potato masher to mash until smooth. Taste to see if you have enough salt and pepper and add some more as needed.
Notes
Potatoes: I recommend Yukon Gold potatoes for the creamiest texture. Russets work too and make a lighter, fluffier mashed potatoes, not as creamy.
Crème fraiche: This is my secret to the creamiest texture. In a pinch, use the same amount of sour cream; the potatoes will taste tangier.
Texture: Start with 1/4 cup of heavy cream and add more, up to 1/3 cup, for softer potatoes.
Mashing: Use a potato masher. A mixer, blender, or food processor can make the potatoes gummy quick. As long as potatoes are cooked all the way through, they will mash smooth.
Make ahead: Make up to 1 to 2 days ahead, refrigerate in a greased baking dish, and reheat covered at 350°F for 20 to 30 minutes with a few slices of butter and a splash of cream.