Copycat Turkey O’Toole

I have an amazing turkey sandwich to share with you today! It’s a copycat recipe of my favorite restaurant sandwich. It’s an oven-roasted turkey sandwich on homemade pretzel roll! Yum!


Do you guys remember a restaurant named Bennigans? If you do, you definitely remember Turkey O’Toole. If you don’t, that’s too bad, it was a nice restaurant. I actually worked there while I was going to college, me and my hubby both worked there. Out of all the restaurants where I worked, Bennigans was the best one. It was like a big family…until it started to sink and eventually went out of business. No happy ending there, just happy memories.

It really is too bad that it closed because the food was really good! I had quite a few favorites on the menu. The most popular item was Monte Cristo sandwich, for sure. I never tried it because deep fried sandwich that’s also covered in powder sugar was not something  that was appealing to me. Turkey O’Toole and Baked Potato Soup were definitely tied for second most popular and my favorites  I loved Turkey O’Toole and I’ve been craving it for the longest time.

Finally, I decided to make it. I used my Homemade Soft Pretzels recipe , without rosemary. I definitely recommend that you get oven roasted turkey from your deli when making this sandwich. The sandwich was originally served with Honey Dijon but I also like Honey Mustard for it.

DSCN4940 (edited)




(Click the above image to take you to the pretzel recipe)Copycat_Turkey_O'Toole_Collage

Copycat Turkey O’Toole
  • (For One Sandwich)
  • 1 Pretzel Roll (recipe above)
  • 4-6 oz Oven Roasted Deli Turkey
  • 2-3 tsp of Honey Mustard (or Honey Dijon) dressing
  • 1 slice of Swiss cheese
  • 1 tsp of oil (to saute the turkey)
  1. Heat up a medium sized pan and add the oil.
  2. Rip the oven roasted turkey in pieces and saute for a few minutes.
  3. Cut the pretzel roll in half and spread the honey mustard on the bottom.
  4. Gather the turkey into one pile and top it off with cheese. Wait until the cheese is melted and add the turkey/cheese to the pretzel roll.
  5. Enjoy!!

Copycat_Turkey_O'Toole_4 ed

I will be sharing this recipe at the wonderful parties in my party tab. Swing by and link up your own projects!

Remember to come back and link up to my party on Saturday!! (this week’s party is still open!)

Don’t miss any updates and recipes from me, follow me through emails| FacebookTwitterPinterest|


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. I remember Bennigans! I loved there broccoli appetizer. :) The only time I ate it as a kid. This looks fantastic!!!

  2. What a great idea for using the pretzels I love! I would love to try this sometime!

  3. Cindy Eikenberg says:

    Oh my, this looks absolutely scrumptious! Those pretzels look incredible…I wish I had this for lunch today! Thanks for sharing, am pinning and will share on FB! Have a great Monday!

  4. Oh my gosh, this looks yummy! I think my whole family would love these:) Thanks for sharing!

  5. Yum!!! This looks wonderful. I am pinning this and will be making it!

  6. Pinned! I think my kids would like these too!

  7. They look so delicious!!!!

  8. oh yes please, I mean, yum…and yes please, giggle. Hopping over to your sweet blog to leave some Hugs

  9. This sandwich looks delightful. Pinning!!

  10. I remember Bennigan’s! Their food was good! And these sandwiches are amazing – pretzel rolls. GENIUS!

  11. i used to love Bennigans, but never had this sandwich. it looks amazing

  12. Hi Lyuba, I just popped over from the Live Laugh link Party as I couldn’t resist checking out your recipe. It looks so delicious! Yum!
    From Mary at Lovefoodies

  13. This looks amazing! I love soft pretzels, so I am sure I would love this. It is a must try recipe. Please consider linking this up at my weekend link party at The Patriotic Pam (opened tonight!). Hope to see you there.
    Pam @ The Patriotic Pam

  14. Yum! Thanks for the idea. Hope you have a wonderful weekend. Can’t believe it’s here already! My
    Homemaking Linkup is live and ready for whatever you’ve got to share. Hope you’ll stop by!


  15. Your photos are amazingly gorgeous. And these sandwiches look delicious. I’m eager to try your pretzel recipe.

  16. Lyuba,
    This is a great Copycat with fabulous flavor! Have a great St. Patrick’s Day and thank you so much for sharing with Full Plate Thursday!
    Come Back Soon,
    Miz Helen

  17. This looks so good! Thanks for sharing it at Flamingo Toes. Just pinned it so I can make those pretzel rolls (and this sandwich soon! :)

  18. Oh my gosh, this looks absolutely delicious! My husband would love the pretzel. Mmmm, definitely pinning, might just have to make this! Thanks so much for linking up to Inspire Me Wednesday!

  19. This looks amazing! Featured you tonight at Monday Funday!

  20. This looks amazing! Those pretzels of yours are just gorgeous! I am definitely going to make this one!

  21. I remember Bennigans! I was so sad when they went out of business. The turkey o’tool was definitely my husband and I’s favorite. We once went to their restaurant and asked if we could buy some of their pretzel rolls and they let us buy 6 packages for a very cheap price! We made them at home a lot. I also have a Bennigans cook book but sadly they didn’t have the turkey o’tool in it. Actually making them tonight and that is how I ran across your post. This time I’m using pretzel rolls I found at Publix. Also using thick cut turkey and homemade honey mustard. Can’t wait! Thanks for sharing.

    • I was sad when they closed too, Ginny. Even though I was leaving them because I graduated college, I still enjoyed the food. I miss their country salad so much!
      Thank you, Ginny! Hope you enjoyed your sandwiches!

  22. What a beautiful sandwich, Lyuba! I’ll bet it’s delicious!

  23. Hello there, You’ve done a fantastic job. I will certainly digg it and personally recommend to my
    friends. I’m confident they will be benefited from this website.


  1. […] / Carrot Patch Cake by the Partiologist / Empty the Fridge Breakfast Bake by Semi Homemade Mom / Copycat Turkey O’Toole by Will Cook for Smiles / Greek Salad Pizza by I Knead to […]

  2. […] / Carrot Patch Cake by the Partiologist / Empty the Fridge Breakfast Bake by Semi Homemade Mom / Copycat Turkey O’Toole by Will Cook for Smiles / Greek Salad Pizza by I Knead to […]

  3. […] / Carrot Patch Cake by the Partiologist / Empty the Fridge Breakfast Bake by Semi Homemade Mom / Copycat Turkey O’Toole by Will Cook for Smiles / Greek Salad Pizza by I Knead to […]

  4. […] Malted Milk Ball Fudge from Lemon Tree Dwelling Copycat Turkey O’Toole Sandwich from Will Cook for Smiles Spring Flower Pot Cake from Ode to Inspiration Coconut Poke Cake from Gluestick Blog […]

  5. […] Turkey Wrap, Thrifty Jinxy Copycat Turkey O’Toole, Will Cook for Smiles Grilled California Turkey Club, Mom on Time Out Lemon Pepper Turkey […]

I love hearing from all of you so please leave a comment! I do my absolute best to answer all the comments.
*Please don't leave your party/blog links in the comment.*
If you want me to visit your site or party, just leave me the name of your blog and I would be happy to visit!