This delicious Piña Colada is a refreshing summer cocktail perfectly suited for any occasion. Made with only four simple ingredients, this Puerto Rican cocktail features frozen pineapple and cream of coconut blended to frozen perfection with white and topped with dark rum float. Soak up some sunshine and refresh yourself with an icy, sweet, and tropical Piña Colada this summer!
Did you know that Piña Colada cocktails have only been in existence since 1954?! I’m not sure how anyone enjoyed themselves at the beach before then. When I’m catching some rays by the water, I like to do so with a creamy, frozen Piña Colada. It was first created by a bartender, Ramon Marrero Perez, in Puerto Rico back in ’52, and I’m so grateful for that man!
There are so many frozen cocktails to choose from, but the Piña Colada has withstood the test of time and remained a favorite for beach goers, vacationers, and summer-lovers alike. And don’t worry, you don’t necessarily need to be at the beach to enjoy one of these boozy frozen delights!
With only four ingredients needed to create the most perfect, classic-tasting Piña Colada. It’s a wonder why so many restaurants charge upwards of $10 for a single glass. Save some money and make this recipe at home instead of wasting it at a tiki bar on a pre-mix and rum cocktail!
This simple recipe is sweet without being overly so, and has rich pineapple and coconut flavors that almost mask the rum entirely. If you like Piña Coladas and getting caught in the rain… Then this is the recipe for you!
Ingredients In Piña Colada
- Frozen Pineapple Chunks – For the absolute best results, chop and freeze your own fresh pineapple. It adds fresh, sweet, and natural juicy pineapple flavor. Freezing the pineapple also cuts down on the amount of ice you’ll need, that way the drink won’t be as diluted.
- Cream of Coconut – Make sure you’re using cream of coconut, not coconut milk or coconut cream. It’s sweet and meant for frozen cocktails. My favorite brand of cream of coconut to use is Coco Lopez or Goya!
- White Rum – White rum, like Bacardi, is always a good choice when blending Piña Coladas. To make things even more authentic, though, use Puerto Rican aged rum, like Don Q, for spicier and more flavorful results.
- Dark Rum – Dark rum is just used in this recipe as a floater, which is entirely optional. I highly recommend it, though! It perfectly balances out the white rum and adds a little bit of spice to an otherwise sweet drink.
How to Make a Piña Colada
Start by cutting and freezing the pineapple chunks. For the best cutting method, follow my instructions on How to Cut a Pineapple.
Divide cut pineapple into portions in separate zip-top freezer bags and freeze them for at least 3 hours.
When ready to make the Piña Colada, combine frozen pineapple, cream of coconut, some ice, and white rum. Blend everything (except for the dark rum floater) until smooth.
Be sure to add just enough ice, approximately 1-2 cups when using frozen pineapple.
Divide the mixture among the glasses evenly and carefully pour dark rum over the top.
Don’t forget to garnish! When you have a fun, frozen drink like this, it’s a crime not to add a garnish or two. Pineapple chunks, pineapple leaves, or maraschino cherries are all adorable toppings. Oh – and of course, mini umbrellas!
Tips For Best Results and Variations to Try
- You can prepare the pineapple ahead of time. Portion the chunks into several bags and use the bag as needed. Pineapple chunks will last in the freezer for up to 2 months if you don’t open the bag. That’s why it’s best to portion it into several bags.
- For the absolute best results, you will need to put in a little extra time. If you want to avoid using too much ice and diluting the flavor, freeze Piña Colada twice. First, blend the frozen pineapple, cream of coconut, and white rum together until all smooth. Then, either place the pitcher bowl into the freezer if it’s safe, or transfer the mixture into a freezer-safe container and freeze it for 1-2 hours. Then, blend it all together again, and if you feel like you need to, add only about a cup of ice. This will give you the strongest and most vibrant flavor.
- If you want even more tropical flavor, add some frozen bananas!
- Do you love more fruity flavor? Add frozen or fresh strawberries to the blender for a fun, fruity twist.
- For even more coconut flavor, use coconut rum instead of white rum.
Try More Tropical Cocktail Recipes!
Strawberry Margarita – this sweet margarita combines fresh berries, aromatic reposado tequila, orange liqueur, fresh lime juice, and agave nectar for a touch of sweetness
Rum Punch – this Jamaican-style cocktail has a base of orange and pineapples juices and both, light and dark rums
Bahama Mama – a sweet tropical cocktail that features coconut rum, orange juice, pineapple juice, touch of grenadine, and dark rum
Mai Tai – a well balanced tropical cocktail that features lime juice, simple syrup, orgeat syrup, curacao, and rum
- 8 oz frozen pineapple chunks
- 8 oz cream of coconut
- 8 oz white rum (or Puerto Rican aged rum)
- 2 oz dark rum floater
- If you need instructions to cut pineapple, check out my post and a video on How To Cut A Pineapple.
- Divide pineapple chunks into about 8 oz. portions and freeze for at least 3 hours. (A whole pineapple will give you 3-4 8 oz. portions.)
- For the easiest and fastest Pina Colada, add all the ingredients into the blender, except for the dark rum floater, and add 3-4 cups of ice. Blend it well until all smooth.
- Divide the mixture among the glasses and carefully pour 1/2 oz. of dark rum on top.
- Garnish with pineapple chunks, pineapple leaves, or maraschino cherries as you wish.
Pina Colada Version 2:
- For absolutely best results, you will need to put in a little extra time but this version will have the strongest and brightest flavor.
- First, blend frozen pineapple chunks, cream of coconut, and white rum together until all smooth.
- Place the mixer pitcher into the freezer (if it's freezer-safe) or transfer the mixture into a freezer-safe container and freeze for 1-2 hours.
- Then, blend it all together again and if you feel like you need to, add about a cup of ice. This will give you the strangest and most vibrant flavor. (But note that it will give you less servings because there will be less ice.)
This is the best Pina Colada recipe! Reminded me of my favorite Pina Colada from a bar in Florida Keys! Will be my go-to at home. So easy and delish. Topped it off with whipped cream. It doesn’t need it, but that’s how they served it in the Keys 🙂 Thanks so much for sharing.
I am so glad you like it, Shar! Thanks for taking the time to come tell me you like it!
Omg! This drink is dangerously good! lol